• Projects
  • Photographers
  • Glossary
Logo
Log in
Logo

Newsletter. No ads. Just Art.

Explore

  • Projects
  • Photographers
  • Books
  • Glossary

About

  • Our Mission
  • F.A.Q.
  • For Educators

Connect

  • Contact Us
  • Submit Your Project
  • Donate

Policies

  • Copyright Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

The Encyclopedia of the Art of Photography

    Beneath the Roses

    • Gregory Crewdson (1962)

    Unresolved moments of ordinary life and unexplained events, produced with film-style crews, controlled lighting, and cinematic special effects.

    Description

    Beneath the Roses, made by Gregory Crewdson from 2003 to 2008 in Vermont and Massachusetts, stages unresolved episodes in small-town streets, domestic interiors, and wooded clearings. The title began as a film treatment that a producer dismissed with "Nothing happens," and Crewdson concluded it could not be filmed. The remark shaped his understanding of the project's stillness and resistance to plot. Location, he has said, comes before story, and he never imagines a before or after, so each scene concentrates psychological projection, transition, and ambiguity.


    Across anonymous streets, bedrooms, back lots, and river sites, vernacular American life appears suspended between ordinary routines and unexplained events. Solitude, domestic scenes, and unexpected encounters provide narrative cues without resolution.


    The large horizontal color photographs combine actual town exteriors with interiors built on a MASS MoCA soundstage. Figures are often small within densely layered settings, held beneath fading daylight, lit windows, streetlamps, vehicle lights, fog, rain, or snow. Doorways, mirrors, and windows divide rooms into frames, while sharp detail extends from foreground props to distant architecture. In Untitled, Winter (Bed of Roses), roots, stems, dirt, and blossoms spread across a bed beside a solitary woman. Summer greenery and wet pavement give way elsewhere to bare, pale winter streets.


    Using a locked 8 x 10 Sinar view camera, Crewdson worked with film-style crews. A final image could combine 40 or 50 sheets of film, merging focal planes and moments digitally to hold detail across the frame. Crane-mounted lights balanced with fading daylight during a window of about 20 minutes, while movable soundstage sets controlled interior lighting. Rain, snow, fog, and fire effects altered the locations. The 2003-05 works were digital chromogenic prints, while 2006-07 images were large digital pigment prints.


    Public reception began while production continued. White Cube, Luhring Augustine, and Gagosian mounted exhibitions in 2005, followed by concluding shows in 2008. Abrams published Beneath the Roses: Images of Small Town Life in 2008. The German edition received a Silver distinction in the 2009 Deutscher Fotobuchpreis. Cincinnati Art Museum showed selections in 2008, Templon in 2009, and Museu da Imagem e do Som in São Paulo presented ten works in 2014. The Whitney holds a 2004 Untitled chromogenic print from the project.

    Behind the work

    Across the 2003–05 phase of Beneath the Roses, more than 200 crew members worked at more than 40 locations. A typical shoot crew numbered roughly 30–40 people, while the wider production chain could exceed 100 people.

    For exterior scenes, the team had only about 20 minutes when fading daylight and artificial illumination worked together. They used crane-mounted lights, lights placed in houses and cars, and effects including rain, snow, and fog.

    The interiors were purpose-built on the MASS MoCA soundstage in North Adams, Massachusetts: sets were designed, built, dressed, lit, photographed, and dismantled. Its ceilingless structure and movable wall flats let cinematographer Rick Sands position lights without the constraints of a real room.

    Artificial weather could be harder to manage than real weather. When early snow scenes lacked natural snowfall, the crew used snow machines; during a later actual storm, a town street was closed for roughly 12–14 hours. For a burning-house image, Crewdson consulted a fire chief and chose a controlled special-effects burn rather than destroy a house.

    Quotes by the photographer

    "I make photos that are between film and something else."

    "When I'm location scouting and looking for a setting and then an image comes to mind, I will never ever think about what happened before or after."

    Tags and context
    genre
    Staged ,Fine Art ,Landscape ,Night
    theme
    Mystery ,Alienation ,Introspection ,Everyday Life ,National Identity ,Melancholy ,Interiors
    technique
    Directorial Mode ,Large-Format ,Set Construction ,Digital Manipulation ,Detailed Focus ,Deep Focus ,Studio Lighting ,Props ,Ambient Light ,Color Film ,Chromogenic Print ,Low-Light ,Internal Framing
    influence
    Surrealism ,Digital Art ,Film Noir ,Genre Art ,Symbolism
    period
    2000s
    location
    United States

    Credits: A limited image selection is reproduced for analysis, commentary, and research under Article 24(1)(3) of the Bulgarian Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act. Suggest an Edit

    Beneath the Roses

    • Gregory Crewdson (1962)

    Unresolved moments of ordinary life and unexplained events, produced with film-style crews, controlled lighting, and cinematic special effects.

    Description

    Beneath the Roses, made by Gregory Crewdson from 2003 to 2008 in Vermont and Massachusetts, stages unresolved episodes in small-town streets, domestic interiors, and wooded clearings. The title began as a film treatment that a producer dismissed with "Nothing happens," and Crewdson concluded it could not be filmed. The remark shaped his understanding of the project's stillness and resistance to plot. Location, he has said, comes before story, and he never imagines a before or after, so each scene concentrates psychological projection, transition, and ambiguity.


    Across anonymous streets, bedrooms, back lots, and river sites, vernacular American life appears suspended between ordinary routines and unexplained events. Solitude, domestic scenes, and unexpected encounters provide narrative cues without resolution.


    The large horizontal color photographs combine actual town exteriors with interiors built on a MASS MoCA soundstage. Figures are often small within densely layered settings, held beneath fading daylight, lit windows, streetlamps, vehicle lights, fog, rain, or snow. Doorways, mirrors, and windows divide rooms into frames, while sharp detail extends from foreground props to distant architecture. In Untitled, Winter (Bed of Roses), roots, stems, dirt, and blossoms spread across a bed beside a solitary woman. Summer greenery and wet pavement give way elsewhere to bare, pale winter streets.


    Using a locked 8 x 10 Sinar view camera, Crewdson worked with film-style crews. A final image could combine 40 or 50 sheets of film, merging focal planes and moments digitally to hold detail across the frame. Crane-mounted lights balanced with fading daylight during a window of about 20 minutes, while movable soundstage sets controlled interior lighting. Rain, snow, fog, and fire effects altered the locations. The 2003-05 works were digital chromogenic prints, while 2006-07 images were large digital pigment prints.


    Public reception began while production continued. White Cube, Luhring Augustine, and Gagosian mounted exhibitions in 2005, followed by concluding shows in 2008. Abrams published Beneath the Roses: Images of Small Town Life in 2008. The German edition received a Silver distinction in the 2009 Deutscher Fotobuchpreis. Cincinnati Art Museum showed selections in 2008, Templon in 2009, and Museu da Imagem e do Som in São Paulo presented ten works in 2014. The Whitney holds a 2004 Untitled chromogenic print from the project.

    Behind the work

    Across the 2003–05 phase of Beneath the Roses, more than 200 crew members worked at more than 40 locations. A typical shoot crew numbered roughly 30–40 people, while the wider production chain could exceed 100 people.

    For exterior scenes, the team had only about 20 minutes when fading daylight and artificial illumination worked together. They used crane-mounted lights, lights placed in houses and cars, and effects including rain, snow, and fog.

    The interiors were purpose-built on the MASS MoCA soundstage in North Adams, Massachusetts: sets were designed, built, dressed, lit, photographed, and dismantled. Its ceilingless structure and movable wall flats let cinematographer Rick Sands position lights without the constraints of a real room.

    Artificial weather could be harder to manage than real weather. When early snow scenes lacked natural snowfall, the crew used snow machines; during a later actual storm, a town street was closed for roughly 12–14 hours. For a burning-house image, Crewdson consulted a fire chief and chose a controlled special-effects burn rather than destroy a house.

    Quotes by the photographer

    "I make photos that are between film and something else."

    "When I'm location scouting and looking for a setting and then an image comes to mind, I will never ever think about what happened before or after."

    Tags and context
    genre
    Staged ,Fine Art ,Landscape ,Night
    theme
    Mystery ,Alienation ,Introspection ,Everyday Life ,National Identity ,Melancholy ,Interiors
    technique
    Directorial Mode ,Large-Format ,Set Construction ,Digital Manipulation ,Detailed Focus ,Deep Focus ,Studio Lighting ,Props ,Ambient Light ,Color Film ,Chromogenic Print ,Low-Light ,Internal Framing
    influence
    Surrealism ,Digital Art ,Film Noir ,Genre Art ,Symbolism
    period
    2000s
    location
    United States

    Credits: A limited image selection is reproduced for analysis, commentary, and research under Article 24(1)(3) of the Bulgarian Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act. Suggest an Edit

    Untitled (Worthington Street), 2006
    Untitled (Blue Period) (2005)
    Untitled (Brief Encounter), 2006
    Untitled (Birth), 2007
    Untitled (The Father), 2007
    Untitled (House Fire) (2004)
    Untitled, Winter (Bed of Roses), 2005
    Untitled, Summer (Trouble with Harry's), 2004

    Books

    91G0SNy+74L. SL1500
    Beneath the Roses: Images of Small Town Life
    • Abrams, 2008

    Related Projects

    Lori Nix and Kathleen Gerber, Library, 2007
    The City
    • Lori Nix (1969)

    Post-apocalyptic urban decay through miniature dioramas with nature in control amid the ruins of human spaces.

    Prometheus Bound, 1999
    Sacred and Profane
    • Calum Colvin (1961)

    Photographic reconstructions of European art within cluttered domestic settings as a reflection on Scottish culture and national representation.

    Morning Sun, 2022
    Hopper Essence
    • Andrés Gallego (1983)

    Contemporary urban solitude in suspended interior moments, rendered through staged color photography and hand-painted acrylic window vistas within life-size studio sets.

    Five People Thinking the Same Thing I. 1998
    Five People Thinking the Same Thing
    • Frances Kearney (1970)

    Solitary figures in sparse domestic interiors, photographed in a five-work staged tableau series with faces turned from the camera.

    Puppy Between Feet, 1999
    Outland
    • Roger Ballen (1950)

    Life on the margins of society for white South Africans during political transition through portraits in staged interiors with animals, objects, and signs of isolation.

    The Empire State Building in Bedroom, 1994
    Camera Obscura
    • Abelardo Morell (1948)

    Exterior scenes within interior spaces, photographed through room-scale camera obscuras.