Directorial Mode

Creating events for the camera by staging tableaux or intervening in real situations, under the photographer's own direction.

The directorial mode in photography describes work in which the photographer deliberately creates events to photograph them, either by staging a tableau or by intervening in a real situation so that something happens that would not otherwise have occurred. The critic A. D. Coleman coined the term in "The Directorial Mode: Notes Toward a Definition," published in Artforum in September 1976. He placed photography on a scale of attitudes toward the medium's credibility, with documentary and straight work at one end, a responsive, interpretive approach in the middle, and the directorial mode at the far end, where images become falsified "documents" that ask only for a suspension of disbelief. Coleman traced the tradition to staged stereographs of the 1850s, the allegorical tableaux of Oscar Rejlander and Henry Peach Robinson, the literary enactments of Julia Margaret Cameron, and the studio allegories of Pictorialism.


In practice, the mode treats the scene before the lens as raw material to be shaped before exposure, not as a given altered only through viewpoint, framing and printing. Photographers cast and direct sitters, build or dress sets, add props and costumes, and often storyboard images before shooting. Staging frequently continues into the print through combination printing, multiple exposure or manipulated emulsion. Les Krims staged mock crime scenes for The Incredible Case of the Stack o' Wheats Murders (1972), and Philip-Lorca diCorcia lit each setting for Hustlers (1990–1992) before paying a street hustler to pose in it.


Coleman contested the moral authority granted to purism, arguing that directorial practice was as old as Straight Photography and that directorial elements appear even in posed portraits, still lifes and celebrated documentary images. Later surveys used other names, among them Van Deren Coke's exhibition Fabricated to Be Photographed (1979) and Anne Hoy's book Fabrications (1987), and the term now overlaps with the constructed and tableau photography associated with Jeff Wall, Cindy Sherman and Gregory Crewdson. It also differs from Collaborative Portraiture, in which the sitter shares decisions about the image, and from Participatory Photography, which hands a stage of image-making to participants.

Key works

sensitive
The Incredible Case of the Stack o' Wheats Murders

Fabricated conceptual photography on forensic imagery, presented as a ten-print photomechanical folio questioning photographic evidence and manipulation.

Untitled Film Still #6. 1977
Untitled Film Stills

Female identity shaped by mass-media stereotypes, documented through staged black-and-white self-portraits.

Eddie Anderson, 21 years old; Houston, Texas; $20
Hustlers

Male hustlers around Santa Monica Boulevard in Hollywood, photographed in staged encounters with sitters compensated at their street rates.

Lucybelle Crater and bakerly, brotherly friend, Lucybelle Crater
The Family Album of Lucybelle Crater

Identity, family, and mortality in masked pairings of Meatyard's wife with relatives and friends, made during his terminal illness.

Lori Nix and Kathleen Gerber, Library, 2007
The City

Post-apocalyptic urban decay through miniature dioramas with nature in control amid the ruins of human spaces.

Young Matadors in the Bush, Spain, 2018
How to Dance the Waltz

Adolescents in formal clothing and uniforms, shown to reflect social structures of identity, gender expectation, and adolescent behavior.

In the New Apartment at the Beginning of the Epidemic, 2020
I am with Me

Disconnection and intimacy between strangers in domestic and public spaces during pandemic confinement.

2008
The Text Book (Chulsoo & Younghee)

Childhood and conformity in South Korea through staged photographs of textbook characters explore the tension between state ideals and individual experience.

Sam Haskins – Cowboy Kate
Cowboy Kate

Woman in stylized Western scenes shaped by 1960s experimental explorations of the photographic nude.

Puppy Between Feet, 1999
Outland

Life on the margins of society for white South Africans during political transition through portraits in staged interiors with animals, objects, and signs of isolation.

Catwoman – Minerva Valencia, from Puebla, nanny in New York, sends $400/week.
The Real Story of the Superheroes

Immigration and work in the U.S. shown through photographs of Latino laborers in superhero costumes to reflect cultural invisibility and sacrifice.

The Omen, 2016
In My Mind There is Never Silence

Otherness in family through traditional costumes in domestic spaces, showing how cultural beliefs shape exclusion, identity, and the need for acceptance.

The Museum Project #001, from the series "Field", 1995
The Museum Project

Human existence in transparent boxes within public and natural spaces as a record of how society observes, categorizes, and remembers people.

Hull Under Water, 1991
The Parents

Domestic life and memory in photographs of a mother and father, from playful scenes to the realities of ageing and loss.

John Paul Evans – Till Death Us Do Part
Till Death Us Do Part

Love between two men through staged domestic images as reflection on family, belonging, and age.

sensitive
Foreign Body

Bodies in flux, shaped by imperfection and contested meanings of identity.

Existing in Costume 1, 2006
Existing in Costume

Staged self-portraiture in Western costume reveals patterns of exclusion in cultural narratives and questions of race and gender.

El Angel, 1991
Lottery

Guatemala's colonial past and complex cultural identity through staged portraits of indigenous subjects using symbolic props and artisanal retouching.

Take Off, 2012
Asylum of the Birds

Symbolic exploration of psychological dualities, staged within a surreal and confined environment inhabited by humans and birds.

Boarding House, 2008
Boarding House

Psychologically charged black-and-white images created in a decaying warehouse, where fragmented figures and symbolic clutter blur the line between dream and delirium.

Ren Hang – My Mum
My Mum

Portrayal of the maternal figure beyond conventional familial roles through playfully staged photographs featuring saturated colors and surreal props.

Grand Amour, Anna Uchiyama, 2018
Grand Amour

Intimate exploration of youth identity, sexuality, and personal freedom captured through spontaneous flash photography.