• Projects
  • Photographers
  • Books
Logo
Log in
Logo

Newsletter. No ads. Just Art.

Explore

  • Projects
  • Photographers
  • Books

About

  • Our Mission
  • F.A.Q.
  • Partners

Connect

  • Contact Us
  • Submit Your Project
  • Donate

Policies

  • Copyright Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

The Encyclopedia of the Art of Photography

    Minamata

    • W. Eugene Smith (1918-1978),
    • Aileen Mioko Smith (1950)

    Methyl-mercury poisoning and resistance in Minamata, documented through a collaborative, advocacy-oriented black-and-white photo-essay.

    Description

    Minamata (1971-75), made by W. Eugene Smith and Aileen M. Smith in Minamata, Japan, examines methyl-mercury poisoning caused by Chisso Corporation and its effects on residents, families, labor, and civic life. During more than three years of residence beside the Shiranui Sea, the collaborators combined photography with Aileen's interpretation, notes, and knowledge of Japan.


    Chisso had discharged mercury-bearing waste from acetaldehyde production into Minamata Bay, contaminating fish and shellfish and causing severe neurological disease. The Smiths arrived during renewed victim activism, after families had sued Chisso and others pursued direct negotiations. Their essay examines corporate responsibility, government mediation, compensation, stigma, and a town's dependence on its dominant employer. It also centers care, survival, and resistance. Rejecting conventional journalistic neutrality, Smith described responsibility to subjects and readers as the basis for an openly advocacy-oriented warning about industrial pollution.


    The 1975 book brings together 151 black-and-white photographs of the bay, drainage pipes, fishing, domestic interiors, hospitals, classrooms, demonstrations, negotiations, and courtrooms. Strong tonal contrasts and close framing move between damaged landscapes, the physical effects of illness, public confrontation, and family care. Named subjects and accompanying testimony resist the anonymity of clinical illustration. Rather than following strict chronology, the sequence shifts among setting, personal histories, and political events.


    The photographers often worked simultaneously, developing and reviewing their film at night. Contact sheets and successive exposures helped them refine the visual approach. Smith sometimes supplemented available light when needed, as in Tomoko and Mother in the Bath, where he combined light from a high window with two bounced strobes. Showing Ryoko Uemura caring for her daughter, the photograph became a focal point of the project's reception.


    Minamata circulated before completion through Life in 1972, a 1973 Tokyo exhibition, and Camera 35 in 1974. Holt, Rinehart and Winston published the jointly credited book in 1975, when ICP also presented Minamata: Life Sacred and Profane in New York. Later exhibitions at the Philadelphia Museum of Art, the National Museum of Modern Art, Kyoto, the Center for Creative Photography, and Tsunagi Art Museum sustained its institutional presence.

    Behind the work

    On January 7, 1972, Chisso employees attacked W. Eugene Smith at the company’s Goi factory, hitting him, dragging him across an overturned chair, and slamming his head against the pavement. The resulting pain, dizziness, and worsening vision limited his ability to hold a camera, so Aileen took over more of the photography while he recovered.

    For the bath portrait of Tomoko Uemura and her mother, the team planned around the family’s after-3 p.m. bathing time. Smith waited for light from the high windows and used two bounced strobes to retain shadow detail, while Aileen interpreted his requests and helped manage the lighting against the afternoon backlight. After several exposures, Smith quietly asked Tomoko’s mother to lift her hand slightly. Aileen later recalled a nearly silent room filled only with the sounds of water, breathing, and the shutter.

    The Smiths lived for three years in a small house in Detsuki lent by a patient family, where a shrine commemorated their landlord’s daughter, Toyoko Mizoguchi, an early recognized victim of Minamata disease. Aileen recalled paying ¥3,000 a month for the house and ¥2,000 for a separate darkroom, with no stipend. Their precarious finances were sustained through television interviews, loans from American friends, and inexpensive local food.

    Eugene and Aileen often photographed simultaneously, exposed about 100 rolls while visiting victims, and developed film at night. Aileen made approximately one-quarter of the photographs ultimately published in the book.

    When publishers initially rejected the book, Lawrence Schiller said he spent $40,000 to finance production and built a darkroom in his Los Angeles apartment so Smith could make the final prints. Smith insisted that no one else lay out his photographs.

    Quotes by the photographers

    "The first word I would remove from the folklore of journalism is the word objective. That would be a giant step toward truth in the ‘free’ press. And perhaps ‘free’ should be the second word removed. Freed of these two distortions, the journalist and photographer could get to his real responsibilities." W. Eugene Smith

    "Photography is a small voice, at best, but sometimes—just sometimes—one photograph or a group of them can lure our senses into awareness. Much depends upon the viewer; in some, photographs can summon enough emotion to be a catalyst to thought. Someone—or perhaps many—among us may be influenced to heed reason, to find a way to right that which is wrong, and may even be inspired to the dedication needed to search for the cure to an illness. The rest of us may perhaps feel a greater sense of understanding and compassion for those whose lives are alien to our own. Photography is a small voice. It is an important voice in my life, but not the only one. I believe in it. If it is well-conceived, it sometimes works. That is why I—and also Aileen—photograph in Minamata." W. Eugene Smith

    "My belief is that my responsibilities within journalism are two. My first responsibility is to my subjects. My second responsibility is to my readers. I believe that if I fulfill those two responsibilities I will automatically have fulfilled my responsibilities to the magazine." W. Eugene Smith

    "We have tried to be honest, and fair, and if our understanding is great enough we may have approached the truth." W. Eugene Smith

    Tags and context
    genre
    Social Documentary ,Photojournalism ,Documentary
    theme
    Environmental Awareness , Social Critique ,Health ,Human Rights ,Disability ,Human-Nature Relationship ,Politics ,Stigma ,Community Life ,Inequality ,Survival ,Family ,Economic & Social Change ,Mortality ,Fishing & Hunting
    technique
    Black-and-White ,Immersive Approach ,Sequential Imaging ,Investigation ,High Contrast ,Unposed Subjects ,Close-Up ,Natural Light ,Flash ,Bounce Lighting ,Contre-jour
    influence
    Social Realism ,Cinéma Vérité ,Environmental Art
    period
    1970s
    location
    Japan

    Credits: A limited image selection is reproduced for analysis, commentary, and research under Article 24(1)(3) of the Bulgarian Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act. MoMA (image source). Suggest an Edit

    Minamata

    • W. Eugene Smith (1918-1978),
    • Aileen Mioko Smith (1950)

    Methyl-mercury poisoning and resistance in Minamata, documented through a collaborative, advocacy-oriented black-and-white photo-essay.

    Description

    Minamata (1971-75), made by W. Eugene Smith and Aileen M. Smith in Minamata, Japan, examines methyl-mercury poisoning caused by Chisso Corporation and its effects on residents, families, labor, and civic life. During more than three years of residence beside the Shiranui Sea, the collaborators combined photography with Aileen's interpretation, notes, and knowledge of Japan.


    Chisso had discharged mercury-bearing waste from acetaldehyde production into Minamata Bay, contaminating fish and shellfish and causing severe neurological disease. The Smiths arrived during renewed victim activism, after families had sued Chisso and others pursued direct negotiations. Their essay examines corporate responsibility, government mediation, compensation, stigma, and a town's dependence on its dominant employer. It also centers care, survival, and resistance. Rejecting conventional journalistic neutrality, Smith described responsibility to subjects and readers as the basis for an openly advocacy-oriented warning about industrial pollution.


    The 1975 book brings together 151 black-and-white photographs of the bay, drainage pipes, fishing, domestic interiors, hospitals, classrooms, demonstrations, negotiations, and courtrooms. Strong tonal contrasts and close framing move between damaged landscapes, the physical effects of illness, public confrontation, and family care. Named subjects and accompanying testimony resist the anonymity of clinical illustration. Rather than following strict chronology, the sequence shifts among setting, personal histories, and political events.


    The photographers often worked simultaneously, developing and reviewing their film at night. Contact sheets and successive exposures helped them refine the visual approach. Smith sometimes supplemented available light when needed, as in Tomoko and Mother in the Bath, where he combined light from a high window with two bounced strobes. Showing Ryoko Uemura caring for her daughter, the photograph became a focal point of the project's reception.


    Minamata circulated before completion through Life in 1972, a 1973 Tokyo exhibition, and Camera 35 in 1974. Holt, Rinehart and Winston published the jointly credited book in 1975, when ICP also presented Minamata: Life Sacred and Profane in New York. Later exhibitions at the Philadelphia Museum of Art, the National Museum of Modern Art, Kyoto, the Center for Creative Photography, and Tsunagi Art Museum sustained its institutional presence.

    Behind the work

    On January 7, 1972, Chisso employees attacked W. Eugene Smith at the company’s Goi factory, hitting him, dragging him across an overturned chair, and slamming his head against the pavement. The resulting pain, dizziness, and worsening vision limited his ability to hold a camera, so Aileen took over more of the photography while he recovered.

    For the bath portrait of Tomoko Uemura and her mother, the team planned around the family’s after-3 p.m. bathing time. Smith waited for light from the high windows and used two bounced strobes to retain shadow detail, while Aileen interpreted his requests and helped manage the lighting against the afternoon backlight. After several exposures, Smith quietly asked Tomoko’s mother to lift her hand slightly. Aileen later recalled a nearly silent room filled only with the sounds of water, breathing, and the shutter.

    The Smiths lived for three years in a small house in Detsuki lent by a patient family, where a shrine commemorated their landlord’s daughter, Toyoko Mizoguchi, an early recognized victim of Minamata disease. Aileen recalled paying ¥3,000 a month for the house and ¥2,000 for a separate darkroom, with no stipend. Their precarious finances were sustained through television interviews, loans from American friends, and inexpensive local food.

    Eugene and Aileen often photographed simultaneously, exposed about 100 rolls while visiting victims, and developed film at night. Aileen made approximately one-quarter of the photographs ultimately published in the book.

    When publishers initially rejected the book, Lawrence Schiller said he spent $40,000 to finance production and built a darkroom in his Los Angeles apartment so Smith could make the final prints. Smith insisted that no one else lay out his photographs.

    Quotes by the photographers

    "The first word I would remove from the folklore of journalism is the word objective. That would be a giant step toward truth in the ‘free’ press. And perhaps ‘free’ should be the second word removed. Freed of these two distortions, the journalist and photographer could get to his real responsibilities." W. Eugene Smith

    "Photography is a small voice, at best, but sometimes—just sometimes—one photograph or a group of them can lure our senses into awareness. Much depends upon the viewer; in some, photographs can summon enough emotion to be a catalyst to thought. Someone—or perhaps many—among us may be influenced to heed reason, to find a way to right that which is wrong, and may even be inspired to the dedication needed to search for the cure to an illness. The rest of us may perhaps feel a greater sense of understanding and compassion for those whose lives are alien to our own. Photography is a small voice. It is an important voice in my life, but not the only one. I believe in it. If it is well-conceived, it sometimes works. That is why I—and also Aileen—photograph in Minamata." W. Eugene Smith

    "My belief is that my responsibilities within journalism are two. My first responsibility is to my subjects. My second responsibility is to my readers. I believe that if I fulfill those two responsibilities I will automatically have fulfilled my responsibilities to the magazine." W. Eugene Smith

    "We have tried to be honest, and fair, and if our understanding is great enough we may have approached the truth." W. Eugene Smith

    Tags and context
    genre
    Social Documentary ,Photojournalism ,Documentary
    theme
    Environmental Awareness , Social Critique ,Health ,Human Rights ,Disability ,Human-Nature Relationship ,Politics ,Stigma ,Community Life ,Inequality ,Survival ,Family ,Economic & Social Change ,Mortality ,Fishing & Hunting
    technique
    Black-and-White ,Immersive Approach ,Sequential Imaging ,Investigation ,High Contrast ,Unposed Subjects ,Close-Up ,Natural Light ,Flash ,Bounce Lighting ,Contre-jour
    influence
    Social Realism ,Cinéma Vérité ,Environmental Art
    period
    1970s
    location
    Japan

    Credits: A limited image selection is reproduced for analysis, commentary, and research under Article 24(1)(3) of the Bulgarian Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act. MoMA (image source). Suggest an Edit

    Iwazo Funaba's crippled hands. She is a victim of the Minamata disease. Minamata, Japan. 1971 © W. Eugene Smith | Magnum P...
    Fishing. Minamata Bay, Japan. 1972 © W. Eugene Smith | Magnum Photos
    Fishermen. Minamata Bay, Japan. 1972 © W. Eugene Smith | Magnum Photos
    © Aileen M. Smith
    Minamata victims protest Chisso corporations’s violence against victims, supporters, and journalists at company’s Goi fact...
    Chisso president Kenichi Shimada during marathon negotiations with Minamata disease victims at Chisso Tokyo headquarters. ...
    © W. Eugene Smith | Magnum Photos
    Takako Isayama, a 12-year-old fetal (congenital) victim of the Minamata disease, with her mother. Minamata. Japan. 1972 © ...
    Takako Isayama, a 12-year-old fetal (congenital) victim of the Minamata disease, with her mother. Minamata. Japan. 1972 © ...
    Tomoko and Mother in the Bath. Japan. 1971 © W. Eugene Smith | Magnum Photos

    Books

    upscaled cover image undefined
    Minamata: The Story of the Poisoning of a City, and of the People Who Choose to Carry the Burden of Courage
    • Chatto & Windus, 1975
    upscaled cover image undefined
    Minamata: The Story of the Poisoning of a City, and of the People Who Choose to Carry the Burden of Courage
    • Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, 1975
    upscaled cover image 9780500410738
    W. Eugene Smith
    • Thames & Hudson, 1990

    Related Projects