• Projects
  • Photographers
  • Glossary
Logo
Log in
Logo

Newsletter. No ads. Just Art.

Explore

  • Projects
  • Photographers
  • Books
  • Glossary

About

  • Our Mission
  • F.A.Q.
  • For Educators

Connect

  • Contact Us
  • Submit Your Project
  • Donate

Policies

  • Copyright Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

The Encyclopedia of the Art of Photography

    Eccentrics

    • Diane Arbus (1923-1971)

    Portraits of eccentrics and self-fashioned individuals in postwar America, presented in direct black-and-white photographs with frontal compositions across New York streets, circuses, and domestic interiors.

    Description

    Eccentrics by Diane Arbus, initiated in late-1950s New York and pursued throughout her career, examines "singular people"—from sideshow performers and transvestites to twins, middle-class families, and other self-invented figures—across a spectrum of apparent normality.


    Arbus pursued this constellation of subjects as her initially consuming obsession and a thread she never abandoned. She proposed it to Esquire in 1960 as a picture story on "eccentrics" — "the anomalies, the quixotic, the dedicated" — a piece the magazine ultimately refused, even as she was already extending the category beyond professional "freaks." The work investigates the tension between the anomalous and the rule-bound, insisting that the "freak beneath the facade" can surface anywhere. At the same time, the project functions as covert autobiography, tracing a photographer from a sheltered background as she refines her experience and seeks kinship with those who, in her words, have "passed their test in life."


    Visually, the series is grounded in direct, frontal portraiture. Subjects tend to face the camera head-on, often centered and isolated within the frame, so that gesture, costume, and gaze become primary carriers of meaning. Whether in Times Square, Central Park, circuses, or Hubert's Dime Museum and Flea Circus, the backgrounds usually remain plain enough to keep attention on the sitter, yet specific enough to register a social setting. The mood leans toward stillness and suspension; people appear paused rather than caught in motion, which intensifies the sense of encounter between viewer and subject and highlights the gap between how they intend to appear and how they are seen.


    Technically speaking, Eccentrics straddles two phases of Arbus's practice. Early pictures from this period use a 35mm camera whose grain and limited tonal scale impart a rough, snapshot-like surface. Soon after, she shifted toward medium-format cameras such as the Rolleiflex, whose square negative and increased clarity supported the precise centering and dense detail that would characterize her mature portraits. Her growing use of on-camera flash, often close to the lens, flattens space and draws out textures—skin, fabric, makeup—so that every surface seems equally available to scrutiny.


    The project’s initial life was uneven: rejected by Esquire, it appeared in Harper’s Bazaar in 1961 with Arbus’s own text, and later resurfaced in Infinity under the title "The Eccentric as Nature’s Aristocrats." These pictures fed directly into her contribution to MoMA’s New Documents exhibition in 1967, where responses ranged from fascination to open hostility. Over time, the work has come to be seen as part of a broader shift in documentary photography toward private, psychological realities and a wider sense of what counts as a legitimate subject, a status reinforced by the 1972 MoMA retrospective and Aperture monograph that have made it a reference point for later photographers concerned with identity and difference in the posed portrait.

    Behind the work

    When Arbus defined "eccentrics", she borrowed what she called the "prettiest" definition from Edith Sitwell: eccentricity as "any dumb but pregnant comment on life… if expressed by only one gesture, and that of sufficient contortion." Her reading of Sitwell’s English Eccentrics gave her a literary framework for seeing such people as "aristocrats" who had already "passed their test in life."

    Arbus would sometimes pursue a single image with extreme dedication to break down her subject's façade; she occasionally used unorthodox methods, such as making a sitter hold a pose, or waiting for a "shoe [to] go on for hours," until the person was exhausted and couldn’t maintain that pose anymore, thus revealing the self lying under their public mask.

    A major element of Arbus's technique was building long-term relationships with subjects. For instance, she first photographed Eddie Carmel, "the Jewish Giant," at the circus in the spring of 1960, but his famous portrait with his parents in the Bronx was taken ten years later, in 1970.

    Arbus proposed the Eccentrics project to Esquire around November 1960. The magazine ultimately refused to publish the story, ostensibly claiming the pictures were too similar to her previous assignment, but management privately worried about being involved with a woman photographing in unpredictable locations. Following this refusal, she was asked to either destroy or return her letter of accreditation.

    Arbus was profoundly influenced by the aesthetic of physical difference and multiplicity. She referred to a twin convention as the perfect eccentric event and subsequently created a large body of work that explored duality, including capturing hundreds of pictures of twins and triplets throughout her later career.

    The iconic image Child with a toy hand grenade in Central Park, N.Y.C. 1962 was captured when Arbus was transitioning camera formats. The contact sheet for this series reveals that she exposed eleven frames of this image, indicating a concerted technical effort for this particular portrait of youthful angst.

    Quotes by the photographer

    "A photograph is a secret about a secret, the more it tells you, the less you know."

    "If you've ever talked to somebody with two heads, you know they know something you don't."

    "Freaks was a thing I photographed a lot. It was one of the first things I photographed and it had a terrific kind of excitement for me. I just used to adore them. I still do adore some of them. I don't quite mean they're my best friends but they made me feel a mixture of shame and awe. There's a quality of legend about freaks. Like a person in a fairy tale who stops you and demands that you answer a riddle. Most people go through life dreading they'll have a traumatic experience. Freaks were born with their trauma. They've already passed their test in life. They're aristocrats."

    "It's irrational to be born in a certain place and time and of a certain sex. It's irrational how much you can change circumstance and how much you can't. The whole idea of me being born rich and Jewish is part of that irrationality. But if you’re born one thing, you can dare—venture—to be ten thousand other things."

    "Everybody has this thing where they need to look one way but they come out looking another way and that’s what people observe. You see someone on the street and essentially what you notice about them is the flaw."

    "The process itself has a kind of exactitude, a kind of scrutiny that we’re not normally subject to. I mean that we don’t subject each other to. We’re nicer to each other than the intervention of the camera is going to make us. It’s a little bit cold, a little bit harsh."

    "I tend to think of the act of photographing, generally speaking, as an adventure. My favorite thing is to go where I’ve never been."

    "I hate the idea of composition. I don't know what good composition is."

    "I never have taken a picture I’ve intended. They’re always better or worse."

    "For me the subject of the picture is always more important than the picture. And more complicated. I do have a feeling for the print but I don’t have a holy feeling for it. I really think what it is, is what it’s about. I mean it has to be of something. And what it’s of it always more remarkable than what it is."

    Tags and context
    genre
    Portrait ,Conceptual ,Documentary ,Social Documentary
    theme
    Identity ,Alienation ,Vulnerability ,Sexuality ,Gender Identity ,Urban Life ,Underground Life ,Entertainment ,Performance ,Rebellion ,Everyday Life ,Human Body ,Trauma ,Human Connection ,Melancholy
    technique
    Frontal Composition ,Black-and-White ,Gelatin Silver Print ,Central Composition ,Minimal Manipulation ,Visible Print Borders ,Square Format ,Medium-Format ,Direct Flash ,Ambient Light ,Natural Light ,Isolated Subjects ,Environmental Framing ,Symmetrical Composition ,Immersive Approach
    influence
    New Documents ,Humanist Photography ,Vernacular Photography ,Straight Photography ,Low Culture ,Existentialism
    period
    1950s ,1960s ,1970s
    location
    United States

    Credits: A limited image selection is reproduced for analysis, commentary, and research under Article 24(1)(3) of the Bulgarian Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act. MOCA (image source); MoMA (image source). Suggest an Edit

    Eccentrics

    • Diane Arbus (1923-1971)

    Portraits of eccentrics and self-fashioned individuals in postwar America, presented in direct black-and-white photographs with frontal compositions across New York streets, circuses, and domestic interiors.

    Description

    Eccentrics by Diane Arbus, initiated in late-1950s New York and pursued throughout her career, examines "singular people"—from sideshow performers and transvestites to twins, middle-class families, and other self-invented figures—across a spectrum of apparent normality.


    Arbus pursued this constellation of subjects as her initially consuming obsession and a thread she never abandoned. She proposed it to Esquire in 1960 as a picture story on "eccentrics" — "the anomalies, the quixotic, the dedicated" — a piece the magazine ultimately refused, even as she was already extending the category beyond professional "freaks." The work investigates the tension between the anomalous and the rule-bound, insisting that the "freak beneath the facade" can surface anywhere. At the same time, the project functions as covert autobiography, tracing a photographer from a sheltered background as she refines her experience and seeks kinship with those who, in her words, have "passed their test in life."


    Visually, the series is grounded in direct, frontal portraiture. Subjects tend to face the camera head-on, often centered and isolated within the frame, so that gesture, costume, and gaze become primary carriers of meaning. Whether in Times Square, Central Park, circuses, or Hubert's Dime Museum and Flea Circus, the backgrounds usually remain plain enough to keep attention on the sitter, yet specific enough to register a social setting. The mood leans toward stillness and suspension; people appear paused rather than caught in motion, which intensifies the sense of encounter between viewer and subject and highlights the gap between how they intend to appear and how they are seen.


    Technically speaking, Eccentrics straddles two phases of Arbus's practice. Early pictures from this period use a 35mm camera whose grain and limited tonal scale impart a rough, snapshot-like surface. Soon after, she shifted toward medium-format cameras such as the Rolleiflex, whose square negative and increased clarity supported the precise centering and dense detail that would characterize her mature portraits. Her growing use of on-camera flash, often close to the lens, flattens space and draws out textures—skin, fabric, makeup—so that every surface seems equally available to scrutiny.


    The project’s initial life was uneven: rejected by Esquire, it appeared in Harper’s Bazaar in 1961 with Arbus’s own text, and later resurfaced in Infinity under the title "The Eccentric as Nature’s Aristocrats." These pictures fed directly into her contribution to MoMA’s New Documents exhibition in 1967, where responses ranged from fascination to open hostility. Over time, the work has come to be seen as part of a broader shift in documentary photography toward private, psychological realities and a wider sense of what counts as a legitimate subject, a status reinforced by the 1972 MoMA retrospective and Aperture monograph that have made it a reference point for later photographers concerned with identity and difference in the posed portrait.

    Behind the work

    When Arbus defined "eccentrics", she borrowed what she called the "prettiest" definition from Edith Sitwell: eccentricity as "any dumb but pregnant comment on life… if expressed by only one gesture, and that of sufficient contortion." Her reading of Sitwell’s English Eccentrics gave her a literary framework for seeing such people as "aristocrats" who had already "passed their test in life."

    Arbus would sometimes pursue a single image with extreme dedication to break down her subject's façade; she occasionally used unorthodox methods, such as making a sitter hold a pose, or waiting for a "shoe [to] go on for hours," until the person was exhausted and couldn’t maintain that pose anymore, thus revealing the self lying under their public mask.

    A major element of Arbus's technique was building long-term relationships with subjects. For instance, she first photographed Eddie Carmel, "the Jewish Giant," at the circus in the spring of 1960, but his famous portrait with his parents in the Bronx was taken ten years later, in 1970.

    Arbus proposed the Eccentrics project to Esquire around November 1960. The magazine ultimately refused to publish the story, ostensibly claiming the pictures were too similar to her previous assignment, but management privately worried about being involved with a woman photographing in unpredictable locations. Following this refusal, she was asked to either destroy or return her letter of accreditation.

    Arbus was profoundly influenced by the aesthetic of physical difference and multiplicity. She referred to a twin convention as the perfect eccentric event and subsequently created a large body of work that explored duality, including capturing hundreds of pictures of twins and triplets throughout her later career.

    The iconic image Child with a toy hand grenade in Central Park, N.Y.C. 1962 was captured when Arbus was transitioning camera formats. The contact sheet for this series reveals that she exposed eleven frames of this image, indicating a concerted technical effort for this particular portrait of youthful angst.

    Quotes by the photographer

    "A photograph is a secret about a secret, the more it tells you, the less you know."

    "If you've ever talked to somebody with two heads, you know they know something you don't."

    "Freaks was a thing I photographed a lot. It was one of the first things I photographed and it had a terrific kind of excitement for me. I just used to adore them. I still do adore some of them. I don't quite mean they're my best friends but they made me feel a mixture of shame and awe. There's a quality of legend about freaks. Like a person in a fairy tale who stops you and demands that you answer a riddle. Most people go through life dreading they'll have a traumatic experience. Freaks were born with their trauma. They've already passed their test in life. They're aristocrats."

    "It's irrational to be born in a certain place and time and of a certain sex. It's irrational how much you can change circumstance and how much you can't. The whole idea of me being born rich and Jewish is part of that irrationality. But if you’re born one thing, you can dare—venture—to be ten thousand other things."

    "Everybody has this thing where they need to look one way but they come out looking another way and that’s what people observe. You see someone on the street and essentially what you notice about them is the flaw."

    "The process itself has a kind of exactitude, a kind of scrutiny that we’re not normally subject to. I mean that we don’t subject each other to. We’re nicer to each other than the intervention of the camera is going to make us. It’s a little bit cold, a little bit harsh."

    "I tend to think of the act of photographing, generally speaking, as an adventure. My favorite thing is to go where I’ve never been."

    "I hate the idea of composition. I don't know what good composition is."

    "I never have taken a picture I’ve intended. They’re always better or worse."

    "For me the subject of the picture is always more important than the picture. And more complicated. I do have a feeling for the print but I don’t have a holy feeling for it. I really think what it is, is what it’s about. I mean it has to be of something. And what it’s of it always more remarkable than what it is."

    Tags and context
    genre
    Portrait ,Conceptual ,Documentary ,Social Documentary
    theme
    Identity ,Alienation ,Vulnerability ,Sexuality ,Gender Identity ,Urban Life ,Underground Life ,Entertainment ,Performance ,Rebellion ,Everyday Life ,Human Body ,Trauma ,Human Connection ,Melancholy
    technique
    Frontal Composition ,Black-and-White ,Gelatin Silver Print ,Central Composition ,Minimal Manipulation ,Visible Print Borders ,Square Format ,Medium-Format ,Direct Flash ,Ambient Light ,Natural Light ,Isolated Subjects ,Environmental Framing ,Symmetrical Composition ,Immersive Approach
    influence
    New Documents ,Humanist Photography ,Vernacular Photography ,Straight Photography ,Low Culture ,Existentialism
    period
    1950s ,1960s ,1970s
    location
    United States

    Credits: A limited image selection is reproduced for analysis, commentary, and research under Article 24(1)(3) of the Bulgarian Copyright and Neighbouring Rights Act. MOCA (image source); MoMA (image source). Suggest an Edit

    Identical twins, Roselle, N.J. 1967
    A Jewish giant at home with his parents in the Bronx, N.Y. 1970
    A young man in curlers at home on West 20th Street, N.Y.C. 1966
    Mexican dwarf in his hotel room in NYC 1970
    Child with a toy hand grenade in Central Park, N.Y.C. 1962
    Russian midget friends in a living room on 100th Street, N.Y.C. 1963
    sensitive
    Triplets in their bedroom, N.J. 1963
    Lady bartender at home with a souvenir dog, New Orleans, La. 1964
    Transvestite at her birthday party, N.Y.C. 1968

    Books

    upscaled cover image 9781597111751
    Diane Arbus
    • Aperture, 2011
    upscaled cover image 9781597115384
    Diane Arbus - Revelations
    • Aperture, 2022
    upscaled cover image 9781644230657
    Diane Arbus - Documents
    • David Zwirner Books, 2022

    Related Projects

    Love in Bloom G-d Bless America, Henry Street Settlement Good Companions Senior Center, NY, NY, 1978. © Meryl Meisler. Usa...
    Street Walker
    • Meryl Meisler (1951)

    American street life and nightlife across changing communities, documented through candid black-and-white photographs from the 1970s to 2023.

    Young Farmers, 1914. Collection of The Museum of Modern Art. Image courtesy of MoMA.
    People of the 20th Century
    • August Sander (1876-1964)

    Typological photographic study documenting German societal archetypes through seven thematic groups, spanning decades and social strata.

    Larry Clark – Tulsa
    Tulsa
    • Larry Clark (1943)

    Unfiltered depiction of youth subculture in 1960s America, documenting drug use, violence, and intimacy through a deeply personal and immersive photographic approach.

    Rural Street, Bryansk region, 2020
    Portraits from the Outskirts
    • Oleg Videnin (1963)

    Provincial life in post-Soviet Russia through portraits of residents in everyday settings, showing the quiet presence of older and younger generations amid visible economic stagnation.

    Nan and Brian in Bed, New York City, 1983
    The Ballad of Sexual Dependency
    • Nan Goldin (1953)

    A visual diary of intimacy, and sexual dependency, documented through flash photography.

    Sandra Bennett, twelve year old, Rocky Ford, Colorado, 8/23/80, 1980
    In the American West
    • Richard Avedon (1923-2004)

    Working-class individuals from the American West, stripped of environmental context by a stark white backdrop.